Most people know John Oliver as the Emmy-winning host of HBO’s Last Week Tonight. But lately, he’s been popping up somewhere viewers never expected: daytime soap operas. After recent appearances on General Hospital and Days of Our Lives, fans are calling for the comedian to make the jump from Primetime Emmys to Daytime Emmys. Oliver’s stint as a soap actor began back in March when, while discussing soap opera celebrity cameos on Last Week Tonight, Oliver volunteered his acting services to any sh