I've been to 20 Caribbean islands. These are the 5 I'd return to — and the 2 I'd skip despite having great experiences.

I've visited 20 islands in the Caribbean. Mariette Williams After visiting 20 islands in the Caribbean, I have lots of favorites and a few I wouldn't return to. St. Lucia is home to great wellness activities, fun nightlife, and delicious food. Although I enjoyed my time on Grand Bahama, this island left me wanting more. There's a misconception that all Caribbean islands are the same. However, as someone who's been traveling to the Caribbean for almost two decades, I've found that each island…