Caleb Williams vs Patrick Mahomes: Who had the stronger NFL rookie season?

Caleb Williams impressed with a productive rookie season, showing poise and playmaking ability despite difficult circumstances. However, Patrick Mahomes made the greater early impact overall. After spending his rookie year learning, Mahomes exploded in his first season as a starter, winning NFL MVP, throwing for 5,000 yards and 50 touchdowns, and setting a benchmark few young quarterbacks have matched.